Three questions to identify it
First question: who appears on the obverse? A bearded emperor with a pointed moustache means the Second Empire. If he wears a laurel wreath, the coin dates from 1862 to 1870; if not, from 1855 to 1859. A winged figure in the act of writing points to the Republic, from 1878 onwards.
Second question: which letter is on the reverse? On imperial coins it sits at the bottom, near the year. A stands for Paris, BB for the Alsatian mint, the only other one to strike this size. The Genius always carries A. The guide to French mints (in French) explains these letters.
Third question, for the Genius only: what does the edge say? The religious formula means a coin from 1906 at the latest, the republican motto a coin from 1907 or later. When edge and date disagree, the coin deserves a careful look.
The Empire: two mints, few coins
A decree of 12 December 1854 created both the 50 and the 100 francs in gold, according to BDOR and Abacor. Striking began in 1855, in Paris and at BB at the same time. Quantities stayed small for a gold coin: the best year, 1857, barely passed 100,000 pieces, and some dates count only a few thousand.
The work was shared unevenly. Paris struck alone in 1856 and 1857; the BB mint struck alone in 1863. With the laureate head, numbers fell further: 1,517 coins in Paris in 1865. Then the war of 1870 stopped everything. The 10,460 Paris coins of that last year were reportedly almost all melted down, according to BDOR, which explains their rarity.
The Genius, from world's fairs to 1921
The Republic took up the size again in 1878 and gave it Dupré's Genius, already in use on the gold 20 francs of the time (see gold coins, in French). The 1878 and 1889 dates match the two Paris world's fairs. For some twenty years striking stayed erratic: close to 39,000 coins in 1886, but only 100 in 1889.
From 1899, each year brought roughly 10,000 to 30,000 pieces, until 1913. The edge changed in 1907. The 1914 date was only struck in 1921, in 1,281 examples according to BDOR and Abacor. The same sources state that the law of 25 June 1928, which created the so-called Poincaré franc, took away the coin's legal tender status. The page on Third Republic coins (in French) puts these dates in context.
Special pieces and copies
Outside regular striking, Le Franc and BDOR list a few unusual pieces. In 1855, Paris made a plain-edged proof bearing the letter A on the obverse, along with patterns. BDOR mentions 1861 proofs on burnished flans, where a five-pointed star replaces the bee under the neck and a six-pointed star replaces the mint letter. Laureate head patterns dated 1862 and 1868 are also known.
For the Genius, 1878 has 30 pieces on burnished flans and two patterns; a burnished flan issue also exists for 1900. The year 1879 splits into two privy marks, the plain anchor and the barred anchor.
Like any large gold coin, the 100 francs has been imitated, in lower-grade gold or in gilt metal. Weigh it (32.26 g), measure it (35 mm), read the edge letter by letter and check how fine the hair or feathers are. The guide to spotting a fake coin (in French) goes through these steps.
Coins it gets confused with
The gold 50 francs carries exactly the same designs, but on 28 mm and 16.13 g, with “50 FR” on the reverse. The Napoleon III gold 20 francs repeats the imperial portraits on 21 mm.
Families in the area also hold gold 100 francs from Monaco, struck in Paris at the same diameter and weight under Charles III and then Albert I: the Grimaldi arms on the reverse and the words “CENT FRANCS” give them away. The Bazor gold 100 francs of 1929-1936, a small 21 mm coin that never circulated, and the late 20th-century silver 100 francs have nothing in common with this coin.
As for large foreign gold coins, such as the Mexican gold 50 pesos (in French), their legends tell them apart.
Spotting wear
The wide diameter shows wear more clearly than on a napoléon. On the bare head, the locks above the ear and the cheekbone lose their relief first; on the laureate head, the veins of the leaves. On the arms side, the eagle, the arrows of the thunderbolt and the links of the collar show the first signs.
On the Genius, the shoulder and torso of the figure flatten before the wings, then the rooster follows. The wreath on the reverse loses its veins.
Being heavy, these coins knock against each other easily: a lightly worn piece can be peppered with small marks, which count when the grade is judged. Never rub a coin to soften them. Look instead at the guide to coin grades and the page on whether to clean a coin (both in French).