Altered coin, copy or original?
Two kinds of fakes circulate. The simplest are complete copies, most often in silvered white metal. They give themselves away on the scales (an original weighs 26.73 g), by a dull sound when rung, and sometimes because they react to a magnet.
The most deceptive are genuine coins that have been altered. The forger takes an 1893 Philadelphia coin and attaches an S to imitate the 1893-S; adds CC to an ordinary 1889; or removes the S from an 1895-S to obtain a fake 1895 Philadelphia. Since the metal and weight are original, no simple test is enough. The area around the letter must be examined under a loupe (tool scratches, traces of solder, a field re-polished at that spot) and the shape of the date numerals compared with a reliable coin.
For the dates mentioned here, show the coin to a numismatist before drawing any conclusion: see our coin valuation page.
The varieties collectors look for
The first year is the richest. In 1878, the eagle first has eight tail feathers; the Mint then switched to seven, and some coins show the seven feathers re-engraved over the eight. A loupe and a reference picture are needed to tell them apart.
In 1921, new dies had to be engraved. The result shows: shallower relief, hair and feathers less detailed than on the 19th-century coins.
Philadelphia also struck proofs for most years, recognisable by their mirror-polished fields. Some circulation strikes have a similar look, which collectors call prooflike. Finally, the Carson City dollars sold to the public by the General Services Administration between 1972 and 1980 are often still found in their original black plastic holder.
Morgan, Peace, Trade: telling them apart
The Peace Dollar, struck from 1921 to 1935, replaced the Morgan with the same weight and the same silver. Liberty wears a radiate crown, and the eagle on the reverse, perched on a rock, comes with the word “PEACE”. The Seated Liberty dollar, earlier than 1873, shows a seated Liberty. The Trade Dollar (1873-1885), created for trade with Asia, is slightly heavier and says so in full: “TRADE DOLLAR”.
Since 2021, the US Mint has reused the design for collector issues in 999‰ silver; their recent date leaves no doubt. As for the replicas sold as souvenirs, with no silver, they sometimes carry a small “COPY” and weigh well under 26.73 g.
For American gold coins, see the $20 gold coin.
Wear and toning: what matters on a Morgan
The Morgan saw heavy use in the American West, but millions of coins never left the Treasury bags. You therefore meet both extremes: dollars smoothed by use and coins that stayed new. On the obverse, watch first the locks above the ear and on the forehead, then the wheat ears and cotton leaves of the cap. On the reverse, the eagle's breast loses its feathers first, followed by the tops of the wings and the talons.
An uncirculated coin keeps a mint lustre that turns under the light. It almost always shows bag marks, left by contact with other coins; their number, and above all their presence on Liberty's cheek, weigh heavily in the assessment. Over the years, silver takes on a grey, sometimes coloured toning: this is normal. Silver polish removes it, but takes the original lustre with it, with no way back.
A dollar born of a silver law
On 28 February 1878, Congress passed the Bland-Allison Act over President Hayes's veto. The Treasury now had to buy between 2 and 4 million dollars' worth of silver each month and turn it into coin. The Nevada mines were running flat out, and the nearby Carson City Mint took part in the striking, which began on 11 March 1878. In 1890, the Sherman Silver Purchase Act increased these purchases further; its repeal on 1 November 1893, in the middle of a financial crisis, explains the low mintages of 1893 and 1894.
With no more purchased metal, striking stopped in 1904. In 1918, the Pittman Act allowed 270,232,722 silver dollars to be melted, most of the metal going to the United Kingdom. The same law then required silver to be bought back to replace these coins: the Morgan therefore returned in 1921, with new dies, before giving way to the Peace Dollar the same year.
In the early 1960s, the Treasury found in its reserves just over 2.8 million Carson City dollars that had never been released. The General Services Administration sold them to the public in seven sales, from 1972 to 1980.